« It's All About Execution. | Main | Permission Denied. »

RSS Feed Facebook Digg it! Reddit Delicious StumbleUpon Mixx!
A Perpetual Game of Telephone

An odd thought from this evening. We were sitting at Kory and Amy's house talking about the strange and unseasonable weather we've been enjoying that turns our yards into mud pits. I mentioned some things that I had heard about Lake Erie's freezing (or lack thereof last year and this year) and algae (or whatever) cycles that I had heard from various climatology friends and how these were out of whack. Amy, the one who's not my wife, disputed what I had heard because she had lived "500 feet" from Lake Erie for quite some time and had not observed what I had been talking about to be an anomaly.
Regardless of whether I was wrong or right (and I was probably very wrong), I had been talking out of my ass based on nothing but hearsay. But get this: how much of academics is based essentially on hearsay? I mean, isn't it a treasured tradition amongst academics and philosophers to gather and discuss things, and then gather with a different group and discuss things more? Think of it this way: I've probably seen Lake Erie few enough different times that I could count them on two hands. My main experiences with this body of water was one time of swimming, a time or two of having my feet in it, and.... hearsay and reading! And I talked about it like I was some sort of expert or something and this was completely normal in my head...?

I do wonder, though, how much academic information and philosophical notions get dilluted in a perpetual game of telephone, or of videotape dubbing in which a generation is lost with each copy.

To be honest, I had no idea whether what I was saying had any merit, even though I had heard people who (supposedly) knew what they were doing talking about it. Then again, I had no idea whether what Amy was saying had merit (though I would trust her more because I generally trust her and she had an experience there).

Then again again, maybe I should just shut the-fuck up.
Share this entry: RSS Feed Facebook Digg it! Reddit Delicious StumbleUpon Mixx!
Posted by Your Friendly Neighborhood DJ on December 30, 2006 01:34 AM |

Post a comment